Skip to main content

Is framacloud.org a Scam? Security Check Results - framasoft.org Reviews

framacloud.org favicon

Is framacloud.org Safe? Security Analysis for framasoft.org

Check if framacloud.org is a scam or legitimate. Free security scan and reviews.

TechnologyFrancesmall
HTML5CSS3JavaScriptFontAwesomeHonKit
Analyzed 9/5/2025Completed 12:29:56 AM
55
Security Score
MEDIUM RISK

AI Summary

Framacloud is a project operated by the Framasoft association, a French non-profit organization dedicated to providing free and open-source cloud services and digital tools that promote digital freedom and privacy. The website serves as a portal to documentation, community resources, and access to their cloud services, targeting privacy-conscious users and the open-source community. The business model is non-profit, focusing on community support and digital rights advocacy. Technically, the website is built using modern web standards including HTML5, CSS3, and JavaScript, with HonKit used for documentation management. Hosting is provided by OVH, a reputable French hosting provider. The site is mobile-optimized and performs moderately well, though accessibility and SEO optimizations are basic. The site uses HTTPS with a good SSL configuration but lacks advanced security headers and DNSSEC. From a security perspective, the site enforces HTTPS and has domain status protections to prevent unauthorized transfers or deletions. However, it lacks DNSSEC and explicit security policies or incident response information. Tracking is minimal and privacy-respecting, with only a tracking pixel from stats.framasoft.org. No vulnerabilities or exposed sensitive data were detected. Privacy compliance is good with clear privacy and terms of service pages, though no cookie consent mechanism was found. Overall, Framacloud presents a trustworthy and professional presence consistent with its non-profit mission. The domain registration details align well with the organization’s identity and history. Recommendations include enabling DNSSEC, adding security headers, publishing a security.txt file, and implementing a cookie consent mechanism to enhance compliance and security posture.

Detected Technologies

HTML5CSS3JavaScriptFontAwesomeHonKit

🧠AI Business Intelligence

Technology stack, business insights, and market analysis powered by AI.

Business Intelligence

Market & Strategic Analysis

Framasoft holds a niche position as a non-profit leader in the open-source and privacy-focused cloud services market. Its competitive advantage lies in its strong community backing, transparent operations, and commitment to digital freedom. The business model is donation and volunteer-driven, offering free services to the public. Target customers include privacy-conscious individuals, educators, and open-source advocates. Growth is supported by a broad ecosystem of partner sites and community projects. The organization maintains a consistent brand and professional content, reinforcing trust and credibility in its sector.

Security Posture Analysis

Comprehensive Security Assessment

The current security maturity level is moderate. The site benefits from HTTPS enforcement and domain registration protections but lacks advanced DNS security (DNSSEC) and security headers that could mitigate common web threats. There is no published incident response or vulnerability disclosure policy, which could hinder rapid response to security issues. Data protection practices appear sound with minimal tracking and no exposed sensitive information. Compliance with GDPR is implied through privacy policy presence but could be strengthened with explicit cookie consent and DPO contact information. Overall, the security culture is adequate but could improve with formalized policies and technical enhancements.

Strategic Recommendations

Priority Actions for Security Improvement

1

Enable DNSSEC on the domain to improve DNS integrity and prevent spoofing.

Observations

AI-powered comprehensive website and business analysis.

AI-Enhanced Website Analysis

Business Insights

Company:

framasoft.org

Description:

Framacloud is a project by the Framasoft association offering free and open-source cloud services and digital tools, promoting digital freedom and privacy.

Key Services:
Cloud servicesDigital toolsCommunity supportGuides and tutorials
Content Quality:

good

Branding:

consistent

Technical Stack

Technologies:
HTML5CSS3JavaScriptFontAwesomeHonKit
Frameworks:
HonKit
Performance:

moderate

Mobile:

good

Accessibility:

basic

SEO:

basic

Security Assessment

Security Score:
70/100
Best Practices:
  • HTTPS enforced
  • Domain status includes clientDeleteProhibited and clientTransferProhibited

Analytics & Tracking

Services:
stats.framasoft.org
Tracking Level:minimal
Privacy Compliance:good

Advertising & Marketing

Tracking Pixels:
stats.framasoft.org
Transparency Level:basic

Website Quality Assessment

Design Quality:good
User Experience:good
Content Relevance:basic
Navigation Clarity:good
Professionalism:good
Trustworthiness:high

Key Observations

1

Website is fully accessible with no blocking or WAF challenges.

🛡️Security Headers

HTTP security headers analysis and recommendations.

Security Headers

HTTP security headers analysis

40/100
Score

Missing X-Frame-Options header

HIGH

Prevents clickjacking attacks

Missing X-Content-Type-Options header

MEDIUM

Prevents MIME type sniffing

Missing Content-Security-Policy header

HIGH

Controls resources the browser is allowed to load

Missing X-XSS-Protection header

MEDIUM

Legacy XSS protection (deprecated but still recommended)

Missing Referrer-Policy header

LOW

Controls referrer information sent with requests

Sensitive data may be cached

LOW

Cache-Control header should include "no-store" for sensitive pages

👤GDPR Compliance

Privacy and data protection assessment under GDPR regulations.

GDPR Compliance

Privacy and data protection assessment

35/100
Score

No Privacy Policy found

HIGH

GDPR requires a clear and accessible privacy policy

No Cookie Policy found

HIGH

GDPR requires clear information about cookie usage

No Cookie Consent Banner found

HIGH

GDPR requires explicit consent for non-essential cookies

Third-party services without privacy policy

HIGH

Detected services: Facebook, LinkedIn

GDPR Compliance Analysis

Privacy Policy0% confidence
Cookie Policy0% confidence
Contact Information Found90% confidence
phone

🛡️NIS2 Compliance

Network & Information Security Directive compliance assessment.

NIS2 Compliance

Network & Information Security Directive

2/100
Score

No information security framework found

HIGH

NIS2 requires documented cybersecurity and information security measures

No vulnerability disclosure policy

MEDIUM

NIS2 encourages coordinated vulnerability disclosure

No security policy documentation found

HIGH

NIS2 requires documented cybersecurity governance and risk management

No incident response procedures found

HIGH

NIS2 requires documented incident response and business continuity plans

No business continuity planning found

MEDIUM

NIS2 emphasizes operational resilience and business continuity

No security contact information

HIGH

NIS2 requires clear incident reporting channels

No vulnerability reporting mechanism

MEDIUM

Clear vulnerability reporting supports coordinated disclosure

No NIS2 reference found

LOW

Consider explicitly mentioning NIS2 compliance efforts

Critical sector without clear security compliance

HIGH

Detected sectors: transport, banking, digital

📧Email Security

SPF, DKIM, and DMARC validation and email security assessment.

Email Security

SPF, DKIM, and DMARC validation

60/100
Score

DMARC not enforcing

MEDIUM

DMARC policy is set to "none"

No DKIM record found

MEDIUM

DKIM adds cryptographic signatures to emails

No BIMI Record

LOW

BIMI displays brand logos in email clients

No MTA-STS Policy

MEDIUM

MTA-STS enforces TLS for email delivery

No TLS-RPT Record

LOW

TLS-RPT provides reporting for email TLS issues

SPF
Sender Policy Framework
DKIM
DomainKeys Identified Mail
DMARC
Domain-based Message Authentication
MX Records
Mail Exchange Records
BIMI
Brand Indicators
MTA-STS
Mail Transfer Agent Security
TLS-RPT
TLS Reporting
DNSSEC
DNS Security
SPF Details
Record:
v=spf1 mx a include:_spf.framasoft.org -all
DNS Lookups:3/10
Policy:-all
DMARC Details
Policy:none0
Subdomain Policy:none
Aggregate Reports:tech-dmarc-reportsframalistes.org
Forensic Reports:tech-dmarc-reports@framalistes.org

🏆SSL/TLS Security

Certificate validity and encryption analysis.

SSL/TLS Security

Certificate validity and encryption analysis

95/100
Score

SSL Certificate Expires Within 90 Days

MEDIUM

SSL certificate expires in 85 days

Partial SSL/TLS Assessment

LOW

Completed 2 of 4 security checks due to time constraints

Certificate Details

Subject:framacloud.org
Issuer:R12
Valid Until:11/30/2025 (85 days)
SANs:framacloud.org

OCSP Status

OCSP Stapling Disabled

📊DNS Health

DNS configuration and security assessment.

DNS Health

DNS configuration and security assessment

85/100
Score

DNSSEC Not Enabled

MEDIUM

DNSSEC is not configured for this domain

DMARC Policy Set to None

LOW

DMARC is configured but not enforcing any policy

Domain Registration Details

Domain Age
13 years(mature)
Expiry Risk
none(416 days)
Protection Level
moderateDNSSEC OFF

DNS Records

A Records:94.130.212.178
AAAA Records:2a01:4f8:221:131d::178
Name Servers:
dns100.ovh.net
ns100.ovh.net
MX Records:
10: mail.framasoft.org
SOA:Serial: 2025082400, TTL: 60s

DNSSEC Status

DNSSEC Not Enabled

DNS Performance

Resolution Time:73ms

SPF Analysis

SPF Record:
v=spf1 mx a include:_spf.framasoft.org -all

Network Security

Port scanning and network exposure analysis.

Network Security

Port scanning and network exposure analysis

40/100
Score

Service Exposed: SSH

MEDIUM

Port 22 (SSH) is publicly accessible - SSH - Secure but can be brute-forced

🔧Technical Analysis

Detailed technical findings and analysis from AI assessment.

Technical Analysis

Comprehensive security assessment findings

Additional Findings

The website uses a modern and lightweight technology stack centered around HonKit for documentation, with standard HTML5, CSS3, and JavaScript. Hosting by OVH provides reliable infrastructure. Performance is moderate with good mobile optimization but basic accessibility and SEO features. There is no detected CMS, indicating a static or documentation-focused site. Technical debt appears low, but opportunities exist to improve security configurations and accessibility standards. The site’s minimal tracking aligns with privacy goals but limits marketing insights.
Analyze Another Website