Is smithery.ai Safe? Security Analysis for Smithery - Model Context Protocol Registry
Check if smithery.ai is a scam or legitimate. Free security scan and reviews.
AI Summary
Smithery.ai is a technology platform specializing in the Model Context Protocol (MCP) registry, enabling AI agents to extend their capabilities by integrating with thousands of community-built skills and extensions. The platform targets developers and AI practitioners seeking to enhance AI agent functionality through a rich ecosystem of MCP servers. The website showcases a variety of MCP servers categorized by functionality such as browser automation, memory management, code collaboration, and web search, providing detailed descriptions and usage guidance. Technically, the website is built using modern web technologies including Next.js and React, hosted with Cloudflare DNS and leveraging Supabase for storage of server icons. The site demonstrates good performance and mobile optimization, with a clean and professional design that facilitates user navigation and discovery of MCP servers. Analytics are implemented via a third-party service (dubcdn.com), indicating minimal user tracking. From a security perspective, the site employs HTTPS and domain transfer protection but lacks DNSSEC and published security policies or incident response information. No critical vulnerabilities or exposed sensitive data were detected. Privacy compliance is limited as no privacy or cookie policies are present, which is a notable gap for GDPR and related regulations. Overall, Smithery.ai presents a credible and specialized platform for AI agent extension, with solid technical infrastructure but room for improvement in privacy and security transparency. Strategic enhancements in policy publication and security headers would strengthen trust and compliance.
Detected Technologies
🧠AI Business Intelligence
Technology stack, business insights, and market analysis powered by AI.
Business Intelligence
Market & Strategic Analysis
Smithery.ai operates in the niche technology sector focused on AI agent integration and extension via the Model Context Protocol. The platform's business model centers on providing a registry and deployment environment for MCP servers, facilitating community contributions and developer adoption. Its market position is that of an emerging startup (founded in 2024) targeting AI developers and organizations building intelligent agents. The platform's competitive advantage lies in its extensive catalog of MCP servers and integration capabilities with popular AI tools like Claude and Cursor. Revenue streams likely include hosting, deployment services, and possibly premium MCP features. The absence of direct contact information and formal policies suggests an early-stage operation with potential growth in governance and compliance. Partnerships with cloud providers and analytics services support its ecosystem. The platform's growth indicators include a large number of MCP servers and active community engagement.
Extracted Contact Information
Marketing Intelligence Data
Email Addresses (1)
Security Posture Analysis
Comprehensive Security Assessment
Smithery.ai demonstrates a moderate security maturity level with HTTPS enforced and domain transfer protection enabled. However, the lack of DNSSEC and absence of published security policies or incident response contacts indicate gaps in security governance. No vulnerabilities or exposed sensitive data were identified in the analyzed content. The site does not implement advanced security headers, which could improve protection against common web attacks. Privacy compliance is weak due to missing privacy and cookie policies, which may expose the platform to regulatory risks under GDPR and similar frameworks. Incident response readiness is unclear, with no dedicated security contact channels found. Overall, the security posture is adequate for a startup but requires enhancements in policy transparency, DNS security, and security header implementation to meet best practices and regulatory expectations.
Strategic Recommendations
Priority Actions for Security Improvement
Enable DNSSEC to enhance DNS security and prevent spoofing.
✨Observations
AI-powered comprehensive website and business analysis.
AI-Enhanced Website Analysis
Business Insights
Extend your agent's capabilities with Model Context Protocol servers. Integrate your AI with 5671 skills and extensions built by the community.
good
consistent
Technical Stack
fast
good
basic
basic
Security Assessment
- HTTPS enabled
- Domain status clientTransferProhibited to prevent unauthorized transfers
- Use of privacy protection for WHOIS
Analytics & Tracking
Advertising & Marketing
Website Quality Assessment
Key Observations
Website is a technology platform for AI agent integration via Model Context Protocol servers.
🛡️Security Headers
HTTP security headers analysis and recommendations.
Security Headers
HTTP security headers analysis
Missing X-Frame-Options header
HIGHPrevents clickjacking attacks
Missing X-Content-Type-Options header
MEDIUMPrevents MIME type sniffing
Missing Content-Security-Policy header
HIGHControls resources the browser is allowed to load
Missing X-XSS-Protection header
MEDIUMLegacy XSS protection (deprecated but still recommended)
Missing Referrer-Policy header
LOWControls referrer information sent with requests
Missing Permissions-Policy header
MEDIUMControls browser features and APIs
Sensitive data may be cached
LOWCache-Control header should include "no-store" for sensitive pages
👤GDPR Compliance
Privacy and data protection assessment under GDPR regulations.
GDPR Compliance
Privacy and data protection assessment
No Cookie Policy found
HIGHGDPR requires clear information about cookie usage
No Cookie Consent Banner found
HIGHGDPR requires explicit consent for non-essential cookies
No Data Protection Officer mentioned
LOWLarge organizations may need to designate a DPO under GDPR
Privacy policy may not be GDPR compliant
MEDIUMPrivacy policy lacks explicit GDPR compliance elements
GDPR Compliance Analysis
🛡️NIS2 Compliance
Network & Information Security Directive compliance assessment.
NIS2 Compliance
Network & Information Security Directive
No incident response procedures found
HIGHNIS2 requires documented incident response and business continuity plans
No security contact information
HIGHNIS2 requires clear incident reporting channels
No NIS2 reference found
LOWConsider explicitly mentioning NIS2 compliance efforts
📧Email Security
SPF, DKIM, and DMARC validation and email security assessment.
Email Security
SPF, DKIM, and DMARC validation
DMARC not enforcing
MEDIUMDMARC policy is set to "none"
No DMARC reporting
LOWDMARC aggregate reports not configured
No DKIM record found
MEDIUMDKIM adds cryptographic signatures to emails
No BIMI Record
LOWBIMI displays brand logos in email clients
No MTA-STS Policy
MEDIUMMTA-STS enforces TLS for email delivery
No TLS-RPT Record
LOWTLS-RPT provides reporting for email TLS issues
SPF Details
DMARC Details
🏆SSL/TLS Security
Certificate validity and encryption analysis.
SSL/TLS Security
Certificate validity and encryption analysis
Weak Protocols Supported
HIGHServer supports weak protocols: TLSv1.1
OCSP Stapling Not Enabled
LOWOCSP stapling improves performance and privacy
Certificate Transparency Not Implemented
LOWCertificate is not logged in Certificate Transparency logs
SSL Certificate Expires Within 90 Days
MEDIUMSSL certificate expires in 47 days
Partial SSL/TLS Assessment
LOWCompleted 3 of 4 security checks due to time constraints
Protocol Support
OCSP Status
📊DNS Health
DNS configuration and security assessment.
DNS Health
DNS configuration and security assessment
DNSSEC Not Enabled
MEDIUMDNSSEC is not configured for this domain
CAA Records Not Configured
LOWCertificate Authority Authorization (CAA) records not found
Domain Delete Lock Not Enabled
LOWDomain can be deleted without additional verification
DMARC Policy Set to None
LOWDMARC is configured but not enforcing any policy
Domain Registration Details
- •Privacy/proxy registration detected
DNS Records
DNSSEC Status
DNS Performance
SPF Analysis
⚡Network Security
Port scanning and network exposure analysis.
Network Security
Port scanning and network exposure analysis
Good Network Security Posture
LOWNo unnecessary services detected on common risky ports
🔧Technical Analysis
Detailed technical findings and analysis from AI assessment.
Technical Analysis
Comprehensive security assessment findings